Will There Be A Recession? Some Economists Say It’s Inevitable, Others Aren’t Convinced

Key Takeaways
- Economists are split on whether President Donald Trump’s tariffs will drag down the economy enough to cause a recession.
- Some see a downturn as a likely possibility as increase costs from tariffs hurt businesses and consumers.
- Some economists think the economy is strong enough to weather the trade war without a recession, with employment and consumer spending remaining resilient.
Forecasters are split on whether President Donald Trump’s tariff campaign will push the economy into a recession, with many seeing increased risks.
That’s according to the 57 economists who responded to a Wall Street Journal survey in April. The poll showed that, on average, the forecasters predicted a 45% chance of the economy going into a recession in the next 12 months, up from 20% the last time the poll was taken in January.
The economic outlook worsened significantly in February when Trump started announcing tariffs against U.S. trading partners. Many forecasters have changed their expectations that the U.S. would experience a “soft landing” from the post-pandemic surge of inflation to bracing for a downturn as the tariffs and other economic headwinds force businesses and households to reduce their spending.
One expert laid out the reasons she expects a recession, another why a downturn is unlikely.
The Argument That A Recession Is on the Horizon
Among the most pessimistic is Amy Crews Cutts, an independent forecaster, who said she was 99% confident of a recession taking hold within a year.
Several recent surveys have supported Cutts’s expectations that a recession is on the horizon. One was a survey of small business owners by the National Federation of Independent Businesses. Over the course of several months, the owners’ moods went from elation at Trump’s election victory to uncertainty about the impact of tariffs. An index measuring optimism plunged since January.
A separate survey of business financial professionals showed that businesses were having a harder time getting paid by clients in recent months, suggesting financial stress building among the companies that keep the economy running. The National Association of Credit Managers’ Credit Managers’ Index, which Cutts oversees, showed the economy was still expanding in March but at a slower pace than before.
Cutts was especially alarmed by remarks managers made in the open comment section of the survey, indicating they had seen an uptick in small businesses simply closing shop without declaring bankruptcy.
Cutts also noted that Trump’s on-again, off-again tariff announcements have wreaked havoc on businesses that import goods from overseas, especially because the import taxes have not exempted goods “on the water” or already being shipped, meaning that some businesses could find themselves scrambling to cover unexpected costs. Canceled orders and financial stress could translate into an economic slowdown and job losses.
Turbulence in financial markets could also influence the economy. People whose stock portfolios have suffered are less likely to make purchases, possibly throwing sand into the gears of the main engine of the U.S. economy, consumer spending. Cutts said that damage has been done even if the punishingly high tariffs are eventually negotiated down or called off.
“Even if I flipped a switch and tomorrow and said, ‘Sorry, joke’s on me, it all goes away,’ it will take us several quarters to unwind the damage that’s already happened,” she said. “So, for me, that says recession.”
Why A Recession Might Not Happen
On the other end of the spectrum is Allen Sinai of Decision Economics, who gives only a 20% chance of a recession in the next 12 months. That’s an increase from the 10% chance he saw in January, but still a relatively remote possibility.
Chief among Sinai’s reasons for optimism is the job market, which has stayed consistently resilient ever since bouncing back from the mass layoffs caused by the COVID-19 lockdowns. The unemployment rate was 4.2% in March, not far from historic lows and nowhere near indicating an economic downturn.
“We’re fully employed right now,” he said. “The jobs count is fine.”
Sinai also sees green flags in data about consumer spending, the pillar of the economy, responsible for 68% of the gross domestic product. Retail sales soared in March, recovering from a dip in January and a lukewarm February, although economists attributed some of the surge to people racing to make purchases before tariffs drive up prices.
A main point of contention between recession optimists and pessimists is what to make of consumer sentiment data. Consumer surveys show that people have been increasingly worried about inflation, the health of the job market, and their own financial situations in recent months. If people pull back on spending, it could spell trouble for the economy.
However, that shoe has yet to drop, and in the meantime, Sinai sees few signs that either the financial system or the job market is buckling.
“It takes financial trouble in the system to shut off funds or the jobs market caves for one reason or another,” he said.